Workers' Compensation One Liners
Jane Lombard
 
 
Download printable format

November 2006
Credits:
Penn State University/PMA v. WCAB (Hensal), No. 1448 C.D. 2005 Decided 11/17/2006.

Department of Public Welfare v. WCAB (Cato),
No. 2521 C.D. 2005 Decided 11/17/2006.

In cases with significant implication for public employers, Commw. Ct. rules an employer may offer actuarial opinion evidence to meet its burden to prove funding of a defined benefit pension plan; employer must only prove extent of the funding, not actual contributions, which is appropriate through use of an actuarial formula.
Hearing Loss:
Hayduk v. WCAB (Bemis Co. Inc.),
906 A.2d 622 (Pa. Commw. Ct. 2006)

Commw. Ct., while agreeing with WCAB’s analysis that a limited asset purchase did not make the employer a successor in-interest, imposed liability for payment of hearing loss award because audiograms on which the employer based its position that the bulk of the loss was pre-existing were not shown to be OSHA compliant.

IME:
Knechtel v. WCAB (Marriott Corp.),
906 A.2d 669 (Pa. Commw. Ct. 2006)
In a case of first impression, the Commw. Ct. holds that the legislature intended “participation” of claimant’s health care provider in an independent medical examination to be limited to “attendance” and “observation;” it rules that the WC Judge did not err in precluding claimant’s health care provider from recording the exam, questioning the examiner, and assisting the claimant in the exam.
Specific Loss:
Agnello v. WCAB (Owens/Illinois),
907 A.2d 676 (Pa Commw. Ct. 2006)
Commw. Ct. reverses WC Judge and remands for disfigurement award; Court requires the Judge to evaluate claimant’s appearance without denture to assess claimant’s “unsightly appearance” where work injury resulted in loss of three lower teeth, this is despite WC Judge finding that he was unable to detect a difference in claimant’s appearance with or without the prosthetic.
Jane Lombard | Chuck Katz | Steve Harlen | Paul Pauciulo
Sharon McGrail-Szabo | Sheilah Tone | Debra Matherne | Thomas Ollason